脉诀汇辨 · Mai Jue Hui Bian · A Compilation and Differentiation of the Secrets of the Pulse · 卷四 Volume 4

芤脉(阳中阴)

Hollow pulse (yin within yang)

Digital translations are being reviewed. Not yet checked line by line.

体象芤乃草名,绝类慈葱;浮沉俱有,中候独空。

Form and image: kou is the name of a plant, very like the green onion; it is present at the floating and deep levels and empty only at the middle level.

芤草状与葱无异。假令以指候葱,浮候之,著上面之葱皮,中候之,正当葱中空处;沉候之,又著下面之葱皮。

The kou plant looks no different from a green onion. Suppose you feel an onion with the finger: at the floating level you touch the onion skin on top; at the middle level you are right in the hollow of the onion; at the deep level you touch the onion skin underneath.

主病芤状中空,故主失血。左寸芤者,心主丧血。芤在左关,肝血不藏。左尺得芤,便红为咎。右寸芤者,相傅阴亡。芤在右关,脾血不摄。

Illnesses governed: the hollow pulse is empty in the middle, so it governs loss of blood. Hollow at the left cun: the heart master losing blood. Hollow at the left guan: the liver not storing blood. Hollow at the left chi: blood in the stools is to blame. Hollow at the right cun: yin lost in the minister and tutor. Hollow at the right guan: the spleen not holding the blood.

右尺得芤,精漏欲竭。

Hollow at the right chi: essence leaking, about to be exhausted.

卫行脉外,营行脉中,凡失血之病,脉中必空,故主证如上。

The wei moves outside the vessels and the ying within the vessels. In every illness with loss of blood the inside of the vessel must be empty, so it governs the patterns above.

按芤之为义,两边俱有,中央独空之象。刘三点云:「芤脉何似?绝类慈葱;指下成窟,有边无中。」叔和云:「芤脉浮大而软,按之中央空,两边实。」

[Note] The sense of hollow is the image of being present at both edges and empty only in the middle. Liu Sandian said: 'What is the hollow pulse like? Very like the green onion; under the finger it makes a hole, with edges but no middle.' Shuhe said: 'The hollow pulse is floating, large and soft; pressed, it is empty in the middle and full at both edges.'

二家之言,已无遗蕴。戴同父云:「营行脉中,脉以血为形。芤脉中空,脱血之象。」伪诀云:「两头有,中间无。」

What these two say leaves nothing out. Dai Tongfu said: 'The ying moves within the vessels, and the pulse takes its form from the blood. The hollow pulse is empty in the middle: the image of lost blood.' The false Rhymes say: 'Present at both ends, absent in the middle.'

以头字易叔和之边字,则是上下之脉划然中断,而成阴绝阳绝之诊矣。又云:「寸芤积血在胸中,关内逢芤肠里痈。」

Putting 'ends' in place of Shuhe's 'edges' makes the pulse cut clean through between above and below, a diagnosis of yin cut off and yang cut off. They also say: 'Hollow at the cun, accumulated blood in the chest; hollow met at the guan, abscess in the intestines.'

是以芤为蓄血积聚之实脉,非失血虚家之空脉矣。时珍亦祖述其言,岂曾未精思耶!伪诀又云:「芤主淋沥,气入小肠。」与失血之候,有何干涉。

That makes hollow a full pulse of stored blood and accumulations, not the empty pulse of blood loss and emptiness. too followed their words; had he not thought it through? The false Rhymes also say: 'Hollow governs dribbling urine, with qi entering the small intestine.' What has that to do with the sign of lost blood?

即叔和云:「三部脉芤,长病得之生,卒病得之死。」然暴失血者脉多芤,而谓卒病得之死可乎?其言亦不能无疵也。

Even Shuhe says: 'The hollow pulse at all three positions: found in a long illness, life; found in a sudden illness, death.' But after sudden loss of blood the pulse is mostly hollow; can one say that found in a sudden illness it means death? His words too are not without flaw.

至刘肖斋所引诸家论芤脉者,多出附会,不可尽信。若周菊潭谓生平诊脉,未有芤象者,抑何其言之不审耶!

As for the views on the hollow pulse that Liu Xiaozhai quotes from various authors, many are forced and cannot all be believed. And Zhou Jutan's saying that in a lifetime of feeling pulses he never met the hollow image: how careless are his words!

虞德恒治一人,潮热微似疟,小腹右边一块,大如鸡卵作痛,右脚不能申缩。虞诊其脉,左寸芤而带涩,右寸芤而洪实,两尺两关俱洪数。

Yu Deheng treated a man with tidal fever slightly like malaria and a lump on the right side of the lower abdomen, as big as a hen's egg and painful, so that he could not stretch or bend his right leg. Yu felt his pulse: the left cun was hollow and somewhat rough, the right cun hollow, surging and full, and both chi and both guan surging and rapid.

曰:「此大小肠之间欲作痈耳。」虞说仍沿伪诀,以寸尺相为表里耳。

He said: 'An abscess is about to form between the large and small intestines.' Yu's account still follows the false Rhymes in making the cun and chi exterior and interior to each other.

然芤者,中空之象,带涩犹可并,曰带洪实,实则不芤,而芤则不实,岂虞之辨证,乃别有据,姑托于脉以明其术耶?否则于理亦不可解矣。

But hollow is the image of emptiness in the middle; rough with it can still go together, but surging and full with it? Full is not hollow and hollow is not full. Did Yu's judgment of the pattern rest on something else, and he merely borrowed the pulse to show his art? Otherwise it cannot be understood by principle.